Bouncy bouncy
Since we switched to the new Chamsocial site various teething problems have arisen, most of which we have fixed. There's one problem that's still outstanding relating to email bounces. First a little history.
The bad old days
The old Chamsocial site did no bounce handling whatsoever, so when email addresses stopped working, it just kept on hammering away at them. To compound this, it also forged from addresses, saying that the messages it sent were directly from subscribers, when they were not. This meant that any messages sent from users on sites that have sensible anti-forgery measures in place, such as Yahoo, free.fr, SFR, AOL and many others, would be bounced by all accounts that received messages from those addresses. In total the site was causing about 40,000 bounces every day, and getting progressively worse.
Playing nicely with others
Persistently sending messages to addresses that bounce is a good way of getting blacklisted, delivery-deferred, marked down or otherwise consigned to spam folders.
There is no point in keeping bouncing addresses on mailing lists as they adversely affect our ability to deliver to addresses that are not bouncing, so we implemented a bounce handling system that automatically disables email delivery to any addresses that bounce. We retain the subscription records (though we didn't at first), and just mark the address as bouncing, so that when we send out future mailings it only goes to non-bouncing addresses. This is all part of being a well-behaved email sender - ignoring what delivery services say just results in your being consigned to spam folders or rejected again.
It pays to be lazy
Now comes the annoying part... The new site is way faster than the old one and vastly more efficient (it did an email run in about 45 minutes; we now do it in under a minute), so we are capable of generating & sending messages very fast indeed, and this has led us into another problem: some big mail services don't like being sent to too fast - if you're working too efficiently they think you're a spammer! Unfortunately hotmail doesn't tell anyone what their sending limits are - one minute you're fine, the next you're blocked, with no warning.
When you exceed send speed limits, most sites tell you to go away and come back later (this is called deferral, Yahoo does it a lot), but others just point-blank refuse to accept deliveries and reject (bounce) the messages, and that's what has been happening with hotmail and related Microsoft domains like office356.com, live.com, and outlook.com. These responses feed straight into our bounce handler, and are thus marked as bouncing and do not get sent messages in future. This is why chamsocial users on hotmail have not been receiving messages recently.
The good news is that disabling bouncing addresses will slowly improve our sending reputation, and sending limits will be raised in future, but re-enabling everybody at once is likely to make it happen again.
The other approach we can take is to limit our speed when sending to hotmail or any other domains that impose send limits. This is called throttling, but unfortunately the mail server we are using (Haraka) does not support it yet. We are looking into ways of adding it, either by helping improve Haraka itself, or by using an intermediate mail server that does have throttling, but neither is a simple fix.
What can we do now?
In the mean time we can re-enable deliveries to bouncing addresses on request - we are planning on making this option visible in your account settings so that we don't have to respond manually.
In the mean time, if you use web mail services like hotmail, something you can do to help is to make sure that the chamsocial email addresses you send to (such as chamshare@chamsocial.com) are in your address books, that you open and read messages when they land in your inbox, and if they land in your spam folder, that you mark them as not spam and move them back to your inbox. Web mail services use these actions to decide whether to accept future messages from our servers, so every little helps.